Investment Banking Interview Questions Part 2

Advanced Technical Questions #

1. “Walk me through an accretion/dilution analysis for a merger.” #

Detailed Response:

“Let me provide a comprehensive walkthrough of accretion/dilution analysis:

Step 1: Basic Framework

  • Accretion: Deal increases acquirer’s EPS
  • Dilution: Deal decreases acquirer’s EPS
  • Formula: Pro Forma EPS vs. Standalone EPS

Step 2: Detailed Analysis Process

  1. Calculate Pre-Deal Metrics:

    • Acquirer’s standalone EPS
    • Target’s standalone EPS
    • Both companies’ P/E ratios

  2. Determine Deal Parameters:

    • Purchase price and premium
    • Payment method (cash, stock, or combination)
    • Financing structure
    • Expected synergies
    • Integration costs
    • Transaction costs

  3. Model Pro Forma Entity:

    • Combined income statement
    • Interest expense adjustments
    • Share count changes
    • Synergy implementation
    • Tax considerations

Example Calculation:

Acquirer:

  • EPS: $2.00
  • Shares: 100M
  • P/E: 15x

Target:

  • EPS: $1.50
  • Shares: 50M
  • P/E: 12x

Deal Terms:

  • 40% premium
  • 50% cash/50% stock
  • $100M annual synergies
  • 35% tax rate

Pro Forma Impact:

  • New shares issued
  • Additional interest expense
  • Synergy benefits
  • Integration costs
  • Net impact on EPS

Key Considerations:

  1. Timing:

    • Phase-in of synergies
    • Integration cost schedule
    • Financing costs

  2. Sensitivity Analysis:

    • Premium variations
    • Synergy achievement
    • Interest rate changes
    • Integration cost overruns”

2. “How do you calculate Free Cash Flow?” #

Comprehensive Answer:

“Let me break down the different approaches to calculating Free Cash Flow:

1. Unlevered Free Cash Flow (FCFF)

Starting Point Method:

EBIT(1-t)

  • Depreciation & Amortization
  • Capital Expenditures
  • Changes in Working Capital = Unlevered Free Cash Flow

Alternative Method:

Net Income

  • Interest Expense(1-t)
  • Depreciation & Amortization
  • Capital Expenditures
  • Changes in Working Capital = Unlevered Free Cash Flow

2. Levered Free Cash Flow (FCFE)

Net Income

  • Depreciation & Amortization
  • Capital Expenditures
  • Changes in Working Capital
  • Net Borrowing = Levered Free Cash Flow

Working Capital Calculations:

Change in Working Capital =

  • Δ Accounts Receivable
  • Δ Inventory
  • Δ Prepaid Expenses
  • Δ Accounts Payable
  • Δ Accrued Expenses

Important Considerations:

  1. One-time Items:

    • Exclude non-recurring expenses
    • Adjust for extraordinary items
    • Consider restructuring costs

  2. Operating vs. Non-operating:

    • Focus on core business activities
    • Exclude non-operating income/expense
    • Consider impact of asset sales

  3. Growth Implications:

    • Sustainable vs. temporary changes
    • Impact on working capital needs
    • Maintenance vs. growth capex”

3. “What are the pros and cons of issuing debt versus equity?” #

Structured Analysis:

“Let me break down the advantages and disadvantages of each:

Debt Financing:

Advantages:

  1. Tax Benefits

    • Interest is tax-deductible
    • Reduces effective cost of capital
    • Enhances shareholder returns

  2. Retention of Control

    • No dilution of ownership
    • Maintained voting rights
    • Preserved upside potential

  3. Lower Cost of Capital

    • Generally cheaper than equity
    • Fixed payment obligations
    • Predictable cash flows

  4. Market Signal

    • Can indicate financial strength
    • Shows confidence in cash flows
    • May improve market perception

Disadvantages:

  1. Fixed Obligations

    • Mandatory interest payments
    • Principal repayment schedule
    • Default risk

  2. Financial Constraints

    • Debt covenants
    • Reduced financial flexibility
    • Impact on credit rating

  3. Financial Distress Risk

    • Increased bankruptcy risk
    • Higher cost of financial distress
    • Impact on operations

Equity Financing:

Advantages:

  1. No Fixed Obligations

    • No mandatory payments
    • Flexible dividend policy
    • Reduced financial risk

  2. Financial Flexibility

    • No covenant restrictions
    • Improved credit metrics
    • Enhanced borrowing capacity

  3. Permanent Capital

    • No repayment requirement
    • Long-term funding source
    • Strategic flexibility

Disadvantages:

  1. Ownership Dilution

    • Reduced earnings per share
    • Shared future upside
    • Potential control issues

  2. Higher Cost

    • Expected returns higher than debt
    • No tax deductibility
    • Perpetual cost

  3. Market Signal

    • Can indicate overvalued stock
    • Potential negative perception
    • Market timing concerns

Practical Considerations:

  1. Current Market Conditions

    • Interest rate environment
    • Equity market valuations
    • Investor sentiment

  2. Company-Specific Factors

    • Current leverage ratio
    • Growth opportunities
    • Cash flow stability

  3. Industry Factors

    • Peer capital structures
    • Industry cyclicality
    • Regulatory environment”

4. “Walk me through a comparable company analysis.” #

Detailed Process:

“Here’s a comprehensive walkthrough of comparable company analysis:

Step 1: Select Comparable Companies

Criteria:

  1. Business Model

    • Similar products/services
    • Comparable revenue streams
    • Operating model alignment

  2. Financial Characteristics

    • Size range (typically 0.5x-2x)
    • Growth profile
    • Margin structure
    • Capital intensity

  3. Market Position

    • Geographic presence
    • Competitive landscape
    • Market share

Step 2: Gather Financial Information

Key Metrics:

  1. Income Statement

    • Revenue
    • EBITDA
    • EBIT
    • Net Income
    • Growth rates

  2. Balance Sheet

    • Total assets
    • Net debt
    • Working capital
    • Capital structure

  3. Cash Flow

    • Operating cash flow
    • Capital expenditures
    • Free cash flow
    • Conversion rates

Step 3: Calculate Key Statistics

Operating Metrics:

  • Revenue growth
  • EBITDA margins
  • EBIT margins
  • Net margins
  • Return on capital

Trading Metrics:

  • EV/Revenue
  • EV/EBITDA
  • EV/EBIT
  • P/E
  • P/B

Step 4: Analyze Trading Multiples

Analysis Considerations:

  1. Statistical Analysis

    • Mean/median
    • High/low range
    • Standard deviation
    • Outlier analysis

  2. Qualitative Factors

    • Growth differences
    • Margin profiles
    • Risk factors
    • Market position

  3. Trading Liquidity

    • Volume analysis
    • Shareholder base
    • Float considerations

Step 5: Apply Multiples

Adjustment Factors:

  1. Size Differences

    • Scale advantages
    • Market position
    • Operating leverage

  2. Growth Variations

    • Historical trends
    • Future prospects
    • Market opportunities

  3. Risk Considerations

    • Business model
    • Geographic exposure
    • Customer concentration

  4. Quality Factors

    • Management team
    • Market leadership
    • Brand strength

Step 6: Determine Value Range

Process:

  1. Select Appropriate Multiples

    • Consider most relevant metrics
    • Weight different multiples
    • Justify selections

  2. Apply Adjustments

    • Control premium
    • Liquidity discount
    • Growth adjustments

  3. Calculate Range

    • Low end estimate
    • High end estimate
    • Median value
    • Weighted average

Common Pitfalls to Avoid:

  1. Poor Comp Selection

    • Too few companies
    • Irrelevant companies
    • Outdated information

  2. Mechanical Application

    • Ignoring qualitative factors
    • Missing key adjustments
    • Overlooking context

  3. Inconsistent Calculations

    • Different time periods
    • Varying definitions
    • Treatment of one-time items”

5. “What factors affect a company’s beta?” #

Comprehensive Analysis:

“Let me break down the key factors affecting a company’s beta:

1. Business Risk Factors

Operational Leverage:

  • Fixed vs. variable costs
  • Break-even point
  • Capacity utilization
  • Cost structure flexibility

Industry Characteristics:

  • Cyclicality
  • Regulation
  • Competition
  • Technology change
  • Entry barriers

Revenue Stability:

  • Contract nature
  • Customer concentration
  • Product diversity
  • Geographic mix

2. Financial Risk Factors

Financial Leverage:

  • Debt levels
  • Interest coverage
  • Fixed charges
  • Capital structure

Working Capital:

  • Cash conversion cycle
  • Inventory management
  • Receivables policy
  • Payables terms

Capital Intensity:

  • Asset base
  • Maintenance requirements
  • Growth investments
  • Replacement cycles

3. Market Factors

Market Correlation:

  • Industry positioning
  • Economic sensitivity
  • Market timing
  • Trading patterns

Size Effects:

  • Market capitalization
  • Trading volume
  • Analyst coverage
  • Index inclusion

Liquidity:

  • Bid-ask spread
  • Trading frequency
  • Institutional ownership
  • Float size

4. Quantitative Considerations

Calculation Period:

  • Time frame selection
  • Data frequency
  • Market conditions
  • Structural changes

Market Index:

  • Benchmark selection
  • Geographic relevance
  • Sector alignment
  • Size appropriateness

Statistical Significance:

  • R-squared
  • Standard error
  • Sample size
  • Outlier impact

5. Risk Management Impact

Hedging Activities:

  • Currency hedging
  • Commodity hedging
  • Interest rate hedging
  • Insurance coverage

Diversification:

  • Product lines
  • Geographic markets
  • Customer base
  • Supply chain

Operating Flexibility:

  • Input substitution
  • Production shifting
  • Pricing power
  • Cost variability”

Advanced Topics for Further Discussion:

  • Industry-specific valuation metrics
  • Complex merger structures
  • Advanced financial modeling techniques
  • Deal documentation and process
  • Risk arbitrage and trading considerations
Previous Investment Banking Interview Questions Part 3 Investment Banking Interview Questions Part 1 Next